Tarot Challenge: How would YOU interpret this reading?

This is a true story, although names and details have been altered slightly for the sake of confidentiality…

A friend of a friend – let’s call her Sarah – came to me all in a flap! She was so excited because she’d just met someone who seemed like the perfect guy – handsome, sweet, witty, rich and worldly. They had an instant connection and she agreed to a date with him on Saturday, just three days away.

She was pretty certain they would end up marrying and having babies, but she wanted to see what the Tarot cards had to say about it.

Her question was what is the long term potential of this relationship?

I shuffled and drew three cards: The Tower, Five of Cups and Ten of Swords.

Robin Wood Tarot

I gave her my take on these cards and she was NOT happy.Β  She was very disappointed in the reading and even though I tried my best to find a silver lining and steer things in a positive, empowering direction, it was nearly impossible!

I will share my experience of this reading in next weeks post which will be called My client hated her Tarot reading (and here’s how I dealt), but first I want to hear your take on these cards…

Your Turn!

How would you interpret this reading? What advice would you give to Sarah? Please post your answer in the comments below πŸ™‚

I can’t wait to read your response!!!
xoxo
Kate

Share this post!
Never miss a blog post!
Subscribe to my blog and get notified whenever I post something new & juicy
This entry was posted in October 2017, tarot challenge, Tarot Challenges. Bookmark the permalink.

49 Responses to Tarot Challenge: How would YOU interpret this reading?

  1. Jayz says:

    Hi to everyone…my vision is the following:
    Sarah and maybe the Guy comes from a past failure relationship, it was something that happened fast and abruptly, but both come from a bad experience…(Tower), at the present moment, this opportunity appeared (5 Cups) as represented by the standing two cups, but, they are still suffering from their last experience, maybe they took a fast decision for dating because they donΒ΄t want to be alone, at the bottom of the heart, they are still thinking about that past experience, in the future, that experience from the past will crash the new relationship between Sarah and this guy…why? Because their thoughts are still attached to that past, so, at the end, both are still engaged to that past experience….there is no future, because they are still suffering.

  2. michele says:

    Wow…first glance it gave me the chills. This supposed great romance happened to suddenly….wham like you were struck by lighting you! There were previous disappointments and hurts. Seeing the 10 of swords as the last card (future perhaps) there will be such a let down she can fall into a depressive state.
    This is a short version. But perhaps a longer one would only lead this girl into an emotional wreck. The positive I can find is… I would say better to know of this now then to really set yourself up for some major hurt. Throw the fish back in the water unless he PROVES differently!

  3. michele says:

    Wow…first glance it gave me the chills. This supposed great romance happened to suddenly….wham like you were struck by lighting you! There were previous disappointments and seeing the 10 of swords as the last card (future perhaps) there will be such a let down you can fall into a depressive state.
    This is a short version. But perhaps a longer one would only lead this girl into an emotional wreck. The positive I can find is… I would say better to know of this now then to really set yourself up for some major hurt.

  4. Ruth says:

    I think she is building castles in the air. She is expecting too much too soon and that’s going to be the reason of her disappointment or depression. She is going to feel like its the end of the world for her. But I think she needs to stop and re-evaluate, take it slow with the relationship, after all its only been one date πŸ™‚

  5. Rebecca says:

    I think she should forget this relationship! Yes this will be a big change for her and the Tower is suggesting a need for her to break out of her comfort zone and make changes in her life but not with this guy! I see her possibly feeling drained and alone with this guy and feeling like a shadow of herself mourning how her life used to be. I think also that he has a potential for being emotionally abusive also. The only positive thing I can give on this reading is that this situation will help her see which guys are abusive and in time she will be stronger. She should keep him in the friend zone or walk away!

  6. Martha says:

    l am new to your site, Kate and am learning so much from all the tools you have created. Thanks to your audience as well. I wonder… would it be appropriate to pull more cards for better insight … and if so, should I ask client to ask another question on the matter first? Pull from top of original shuffled deck? Reshuffle deck, then pull cards? Things do not appear to very good for her to peruse this relationship, but the sunrise in the 10 of swords leaves me wanting a little more…

    • Hi Martha,
      Apologies for my late reply here.
      Yes, If you were doing this reading for someone I think it would be fine to draw more cards for extra insight. If a new question is asked, I would reshuffle and draw πŸ™‚

  7. Cher says:

    Wow. First, I’m responding to this before reading others’ comments.

    The long term potential of this relationship is very destructive. In this case, the worse thing I see is that there is a long term relationship. It would have been better for her if the cards had suggested no potential at all.

    The relationship will bring about major changes in Sarah’s life, she will become isolated and feel complete defeat. If this was my client, I would strongly suggest canceling the date all together. I honestly don’t see any silver lining at all in these cards.

  8. Dawn Taylor says:

    I would say this is not good he’s not right for her. He doesn’t feel the same way she does. She well find herself alone feeling worthless and despondent. She well have pent up feelings and feeling very bitter. Better off putting a stop to this now and cutting her losses.

  9. Cindy Brashares says:

    Initially there would be romantic chemistry and sparks. But she has set her expectations to high for this person and she would fine the relationship wanting or something missing and in the end it would be painful unfulfilling experience. To move forward the client would better serve herself to focus on what she wants to receive from a relationship. Make a list of the qualities she wants to see in her significant other and then make the request of the universe to bring her a significant other into her life with those qualities. Once that is done pay attention, stay open/receptive and be patient.

  10. Cindy says:

    Like everyone else, my reaction to these cards was, “Holy cr@p!” But I asked the cards why.

    She just met this guy and mentally flew a few years down the road to married with children. It seems to me that she is engaging in magical thinking. I would ask her questions about her definition of happiness, love, communication, etc. These “values” have different meanings to different people.

    When I asked the cards why this spread showed such a negative outcome, I received the 6 of Pentacles reversed. There will be problems with giving and receiving, with expectation, with distribution of resources, with flow…a major power imbalance.

    She needs to get clear in her mind on what her values are…in specific terms, and be able to communicate these needs to future potential mates before she mentally leaps ahead to the altar with a total stranger.

    Her fantasy, if it is just a fantasy, may be harmless. But if she shackles her potential mate with these fantasy expectations without a firm grounding in reality, she’s facing a painful life lesson.

  11. Charleen says:

    I interpreted this reading as she has had big dating disasters or unexpected results (the tower) which now she needs to heal from the loss or get over her “unhappy” reading ( 5 of cups) otherwise she will hit rock bottom with this relationship. (10 of swords). I don’t think it’s saying no…just that she has work to do with herself or THIS relationship will not be in her best interest or highest good.

  12. Arabella says:

    This relationship is going to turn her world upside down and definitely not for the better! She will end up regretting it. And someone is going to get badly hurt in the end. (My first reaction to that 10 of Swords was suicidal…yikes!)

  13. Steph says:

    I believe she will find out that he drinks….Too much! He may be hiding it, or have an addiction.

  14. Elizabeth Esquivel says:

    I think that her relationship has no potential because the tower for me is distruction which it could possibly be she found out something in which it completely made drastic changes. I’d say maybe cheating which with the 5 of cups means she is not happy, she is sadden or depressed and with the 10 of swords she feels she has been awfully betrayed and hurted by that person.

    So maybe the reason is she found out she was cheated on and felt into depression and feels hurted.

    And the reason she asks if her relationship has pontential maybe is to know if its worth staying together.

  15. Learning My Gift says:

    The relationship definitely shakes up her life and turns it upside down which may seem like blinding love but the quiet voice inside is telling her that’s not the case nonetheless she to is ignoring her intuition and carrying on with her silver lining illusion in the end she’s sabotaging herself. 😳

  16. Twyla says:

    I always ask the other person to look over the cards and see what they look like to them, so that when I have to give the “bad” news she has already seen it…

  17. Andrew Hurley says:

    Strong attraction, fireworks infact. Something is not right with this fella.
    The image he portrays is not who he really is and sadly she will get hurt. She will be depressed but will get over it. Is he already married snd looking for a fling? Advise her, by all means have a date with this fella, but be aware all may not be what it seams.

  18. Nicole says:

    Phew! I would love to hear how you handled her after she heard the news.
    The relationship will be rocky to say the least, not a safe haven for love and romance. She will always be wondering about him and as time progresses she will not be able to fully trust him. Her world as she knows it will be shaken upside down, she will yearn for the past – perhaps more peace and steadiness. She will always be looking back at the bad things, not looking forward to anything they have build together or to a bright and happy future. All in all very unsettling. She will ultimately be or feel very betrayed, he could be spreading rumours about her which are false, or be seeing someone else behind her back. He definitely will not have her back when she needs it the most and the relationship, unfortunately is doomed to fail. πŸ™

  19. wren says:

    ooh, the first thought process i had when i glanced at the cards were: a sudden negative change brought on by this relationship (the tower), then seeing the negatives of the situation when there are also positives (5 of cups), and bringing on the martyr aspect of the 10 of swords, i feel like she sees the reading itself and kind of shoots herself in the foot with it. Its kind of meta in a way, that the reading itself is talking about how it will affect this querent. Does that make sense? I’m confused now!

  20. Sofia Fortuno says:

    Sure, this relationship will change your life. Maybe you will get married, maybe you will have babies, but in the long term, it will be a tragedy. You’ll need to be your own tower and deconstruct what you perceive to be the “ideal guy.” This is a new, potentially fruitful project! You may have spilled three cups in the process, but remember those two preserved glittering cups and drink from them! If you forget them, you’ll be doomed to drown in self pity.

  21. Liz says:

    I don’t usually take the cards literally, but in this case I had a strong gut feeling that this guy is dangerous. The words, “He’s spilled blood before,” popped into my head. I fear for her safety if she dates him.

    I’ve done readings for friends and family and had these card come up at various times, but never have I felt this!

  22. Kathy says:

    To go forth with this relationship would be life altering and not in a good way. It may be time to focus on herself and the needs and beliefs she holds around love and relationships to create a more healthy foundation. Exploring her shadow self and bringing it to consciousness will help her avoid unnecessary pain.

  23. Susan says:

    Wow, no words are needed with this spread YIKES! Interestingly, my first impression was (and I tend to do this – that is why I should take your class) I see this as his reading, not hers. This guy has a history of fast relationships, broken hearts, and quickly moving on. I feel like he just rebounded from a bad relationship and he is quickly hopping into another one. Or I can be wrong, perhaps this is what she does, but you don’t want to say that to her! If I was to read her question “what is my long term relationship with this guy” – the Tower could be positive, a very fireworks explosive attraction for each other. But it will fizzle out via the 5 of cups with a feeling of disappointment or a hurt that takes place between you two and the attraction begins to simmered down. This is the time I would give the client a heads-up on a word of caution with this dude, that you might be feeling hurt or some form of disappointment with the 5 of Cups, but now is the time to evaluate this guy, take your power back and consider moving on before the 10 of swords swoops in for real disappointment and hurt. Being in the 5 of Cups situation, is a turning point decision on her part. She can choose to try to salvage the relationship with the two cups behind you and try to make something work that potentially will not and spare yourself the time and more hurt as indicated in the 10 of Swords. I don’t know why, but I also feel like he will take advantage of her financially as well. Will you be critiquing our interpretations? Thank you for this practice. More please.

  24. Karen says:

    I believe Sarah isn’t ready for a relationship at the moment. I think she is in the process of going through a transformation & maybe a recent relationship ended abruptly leaving her feeling lost, unfulfilled & rejected. This new relationship will not survive as she will not be able to trust him or they’ll always be some reason why she doubts the relationship. I would advise Sarah to take some time out to heal herself, give it 6 months then she may have a different energy surrounding her relationships.

  25. I know this appears all doom and gloom, but for me, the 10 of swords can represent “the light after the storm” with the sun rising over the mental exasperation. Her belief of who and what this guy is will be burned down and she might be devastated, but once that sun shines past her grief, she will hopefully be able to see exactly why she needed to go through the experience. No matter how bad it may play out, it will complete a new belief, either in self or relationships.

  26. Martin says:

    I read this as totally positive. Here’s how I saw things:

    The relationship has come as a total surprise.

    Don’t focus on what she has lost, but what she has.

    The waiting around for mister right is now over.

  27. Gwenelan says:

    I love a challenge *-*!
    But, it is difficult to see something good in this relationship… although I do think there is a silver lining in the reading itself.
    Now, if I had dealt the cards, I would say that this could be an amazing *sexual* relationship, but it will leave her sad and disappointed. What I also see, though, it’s a way to be shaken and made stronger. The Tower shakes up some preconceived ideas she has about love or relationships; the 5 of Cups is the necessary period of mourning and sadness, while she adapts to her new reality; with the 10 of Swords she stops fighting the truth, she accepts reality and she can start anew, with a new strength and a couple of personal battles won. So this relationship will be hard and there will be a lot of sadness, but it can help her become a better and stronger person, if she doesn’t fight the Tower, which will shake some very strong ideas she has about love, life, herself or her partner.

  28. Subhra says:

    Okay first things first. This is not the relationship for her if she us looking for love, a wedding and eventually babies and a perfect family. This relationship will not exactly be what she is looking for. There is a potential heartreak in case this happens and I honestly do not get positive vibes out of it. The good part is that, she has not yet started dating him. And this is all a possibility. With that said, nothing can predict the future, not even Tarot. So I would tell her, if she really wants to explore this, she can. However, this reading’s outcome is one of the possibilities. Be mindful of that and go ahead with what ultimately her heart says. β™₯β™₯

    • Joan says:

      I really like this interpretation because it allows her to make her own decision at the same time she is made aware of the potential for disappointment and heartbreak.
      . .

  29. Heather says:

    I interpret the cards as Sarah meets a person that really shakes her to the core. He’s “perfect” in her eyes, the intense attraction and her happily ever after daydreaming, to me, is shown through The Tower. The next card says to me that he is hiding something big. As soon as I saw the spread, I immediately thought Sarah’s life is going to be rocked, he’s hiding something (either a past event, or a violent shadow side) and when it comes to light it’s going to be catastrophic, leading to betrayal and back stabbing, and at the very least the death of their relationship. The last card representing the end of their relationship and it changing Sarah in the long run, changing her ability to cope in future relationships. Perhaps leaving her having to cope with the aftermath of abuse. To put a positive/empowering spin to the reading, I would have emphasized her ability to make the choice to either not move forward with the relationship or at the very least her ability to go forward with her eyes wide open so she could be on the alert for anything shady, and perhaps asking different questions to uncover things that he could be hiding. That would have been a tough reading to do!

  30. K says:

    Whenever I am faced with cards that seem so obviously negative to me, then I start by asking the querent to first describe the cards and then to tell me what kind of emotions and insights those cards evoke in them (without me telling them anything about my feelings/intuitions or the traditional meanings of those cards). Sometimes they have a completely different take on those cards, so that a typically “negative” card feels interesting or positive for them, or a typically happy cards can bring up lots of shadow material (like, 3 of cups: While I might see friends celebrating and having fun together, for the querent that card might evoke feelings of being left out, or of “mean girls”. And perhaps a card like The Devil reminds them of good times in the bedroom 😁) But if they also get the same negative feeling (like I am sure your friend did) then I find it is often easier for them to come to that interpretation/conclusion on their own (and they are less likely to want to shoot the messenger 😜)

  31. Nancy says:

    OMG this relationship is a ticking time bomb and when it blows, Sarah is going to find herself in a deep depression feeling like its the end of life as she knows it. She will get through this but better yet, avoid this relationship to begin with! Run, girl, run!

  32. Robin Casey says:

    Wow Kate.This definitely does not look promising for Sarah. THE TOWER looks very catastrophic.I see the 5 OF CUPS as choice making (ie 3 cups fallen over and 2 cups standing).She must decide on which steps she should take.The figure in this card appears to be pondering over what to do,which path to take.The 10 of SWORDS could mean disaster for Sarah.
    There is a difficult situation facing Sarah in this spread. I think that she ought to tread very carefully and not be too hasty about this relationship.

  33. Mariann says:

    Things may not have been so sure and certain as Sarah thought. Maybe she has discovered some truth(s) about the person that she doesn’t like. (I would ask her that, as my intuition say so.) If she chooses to be with him, it will end up in sorrow and regret, and most lightly Sarah will end up with a violent abuser.

  34. Susan says:

    Sarah’s life may have been going through some chaos and change and she meets someone who maybe gives her a calming port in the storm or offers her something she is looking for at the time. She turns her back on others or circumstances that were a constant in her life only to find out that the guy she is involved with turns out to not be all she had hoped for and she is devastated.

  35. simplysharon says:

    The relationship comes into her life totally upsetting her normalcy as she knows it. However, it doesn’t end up being a happy change. She trades her long time friends that have always been there for her, for betrayal. He uses her, leaves her , and she’s left alone to pick up the pieces.

  36. Ru.talaa says:

    Oh my goodness!!! I even pulled a card for her to see what she can do so it doesn’t End in the backstabbing, Using my tarot Deck Joie de Vivre By Paulina Cassidy I pulled the 8 of Cups Which I interpreted as she needs to leave take her heart with her which I see as the basket of pretty flowers. There is just no way to save the relationship.there is some else out there for her just not him.

  37. Mela says:

    Oh WOW!!! Run away with all speed!!! This is my take on this:
    The Tower signifies discord, catastrophe, confusion and chaos. There can be complications, frustrations, all sorts of mess. You will not be the same after these events. Be warned! It’s very telling how the bottom of the card shows the tower solid yet dark but by the top all is 50 shades of crazy! It’s like you are stepping into a bad situation and when you reach the top it’s out of control.
    5 of Cups – signifies negative events or happenings. The caped figure looks in despair, head down, possible shame, sadness, withdrawn, cold and alone. The cup’s contents have been spilled. This person is facing depression. They will not be left with much. (two cups standing.) They will lose alot.
    10 of Swords – signifies tough or dark times ahead. It’s going to be a hard fight. Exhaustion. You won’t be defeated (it’ll take “10 swords to bring you down”) but you will be wounded in the situation. You will need help to recover.
    The Friend is strong – there is alot of strength in this person but this relationship will push them beyond a point where it will be hard to recover. It will change them.

    The silver lining is that the friend is being forewarned. Don’t go on this date with your mind set on rainbows and unicorns and butterflies. She needs to stay focused and grounded if she goes on this date. It would be fruitless to tell her not to go on the date because she sounds set on doing it anyway if she hated the reading. But I would urge (plead!) her to not let things slide or ignore even the little things. Keep a scorecard and compare the pros and cons of there conversations, meetings, etc. And to please be careful!!!
    Thank you so much for opening this reading for us to learn and interpret also! I really enjoyed this idea! Will you be doing this again?

  38. Suzanne Muir says:

    Yikes! Quite a lot of bad news to have to deliver to the querent. I can’t wait to hear how you navigated that minefield .

    I suppose the gentlest way to deliver the news would be to suggest that she go slow going into the relationship: make him work to win her heart while keeping her wits about her because there is a strong possibility that Mr. Perfect is not. I would encourage her to play hard to get and find out as much about the man as she can before she lets him get close. If she allows herself to be swept off her feet , as she would appear inclined to do, she will likely experience heartbreak and it will be all the more painful because she will feel totally betrayed.

    If that reading is completely off-base , she will lose nothing for having proceeded with caution . If the guy really is a gem , he will love her all more for having made him work to win her heart.

  39. Ru.talaa says:

    What I interpret in this reading is I get the feeling she is going to find out something that is going to give her a left-upper-right -cross hit to the gut and even though she is sad about it and wants to find something good in it ends with just digging in the dagger deeper…she should not expect any thing and and leave while she is ahead πŸ˜”

  40. Sue freake says:

    The “silver lining” is, she had her cards read.

  41. Tara Viribusay says:

    I agree. It is difficult to add positive to this one…
    The querent is still holding on to feeling from her previous relationship which toppled her world. Deep down she is feeling grave loss and is attempting to supplement her hurt in the new “relationship.” This will lead to the new relationship and her demise emotionally, intellectually, and spiritually.
    That was a tough one.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *